The leadership dispute at The Fountain of Life Church over Pastor Jimmy Odukoya’s position as Senior Pastor has renewed attention on how major Nigerian Christian denominations plan for leadership succession.
The controversy followed an announcement by a section of the church’s Board of Trustees that it no longer recognised Jimmy Odukoya as Senior Pastor and had appointed Pastor Rotimi Okpaise as interim spiritual and administrative leader.
Also read: Musk regrets spending millions on failed US election campaigns
The trustees cited governance concerns and information about the succession preference of the late founder, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya.
However, Jimmy Odukoya and his supporters rejected the decision, insisting that he remained the duly appointed Senior Pastor and Chairman of the Board of Trustees.
They also questioned the authority of the trustees behind the announcement.
The disagreement has brought into focus the succession arrangements of three influential Nigerian church leaders: Pastor Enoch Adeboye of the Redeemed Christian Church of God, Pastor William Kumuyi of the Deeper Christian Life Ministry and Bishop David Oyedepo of Living Faith Church Worldwide, popularly known as Winners’ Chapel.
Although the clerics have different approaches to the issue, their public statements indicate that they do not support the automatic transfer of church leadership to biological children.
Pastor Enoch Adeboye, who has led the RCCG since 1981, has repeatedly maintained that God would reveal his successor at the appropriate time.
Speaking during the church’s ministers’ conference at Redemption Camp, Ogun State, in August 2018, he dismissed speculation that he would hand over the position to Bishop David Oyedepo, Pastor Joe Olaiya or one of his sons.
Adeboye explained that, based on his understanding of biblical succession, God would inform him before making the identity of the next leader known to others.
“Elijah knew before Elisha knew that he would succeed him; Moses also knew that Joshua would succeed him and likewise Eli knew before Samuel and not the other way round and therefore, God will tell me first before any other person about who will become my successor as a general overseer,” he said.
He further disclosed that God had promised to reveal the successor at least five years before his death.
“What God had told me several years ago was that He would tell me who my successor would be at least five years before I would be called home, and as at this now, He had not told me anything as regards that,” he said.
Adeboye also warned that succeeding him would require considerable sacrifice, noting that the next leader would have to surpass his commitment to prayer and other spiritual responsibilities.
In January 2017, he stepped down as General Overseer of the RCCG in Nigeria, with Pastor Joseph Obayemi appointed National Overseer. Adeboye, however, retained his position as General Overseer of RCCG Worldwide.
Pastor William Kumuyi has rejected suggestions that leadership of the Deeper Christian Life Ministry should be handed over to one of his biological children.
In June 2026, he addressed speculation about his successor during a church service, insisting that the ministry belonged to Jesus Christ and was not his personal property.
“Our attention has been drawn to the fact that some people are saying, ‘Is he going to hand over the church to his son?’ It’s the church of the Lord Jesus Christ and nobody has the right to hand it over to his son,” he said.
He cited biblical examples, arguing that prominent figures in the early Christian church did not transfer leadership to their children.
Kumuyi had also addressed the matter in August 2025, expressing displeasure over what he described as subtle pressure within the church for him to identify a successor.
During a Bible study programme, he questioned whether some members were becoming impatient with his leadership after an unnamed young preacher repeatedly suggested that leadership required a successor.
“Are you tired of me?” he asked the congregation.
He maintained that members should not attempt to pressure him into leaving office, insisting that the decision about his successor rested with God.
Kumuyi, however, acknowledged that another leader would eventually take over the ministry.
When the time comes, God will choose a man after His own heart.
Don’t try to drive me away, even though I know you cannot, he said.
Unlike Adeboye and Kumuyi, who have emphasised divine direction in choosing their successors, Bishop David Oyedepo has spoken publicly about a formal succession procedure contained in a church document titled The Mandate.
In a sermon reported by Daily Times Nigeria in June 2020, Oyedepo explained that the procedure required the presiding bishop to submit three names to the Council of Priests upon attaining the age of 70.
The nominees would then be assessed by the church secretariat to determine whether they met the required qualifications.
If none was considered suitable, the names would be returned to the presiding bishop, who would be allowed to submit another list.
Should the second submission also fail, the Council of Priests would take over the process, while the Board would ratify the eventual decision.
Oyedepo described the arrangement as a structured process designed to prevent uncertainty during leadership transitions.
When you are 70 as leader of this Church, you present 3 names to the Council of Priests for them to see if any of them is qualified by the Secretariat.
If they are not qualified, throw it back to you, you have one more chance to make another presentation and after that, you are out of it.
The Council takes it, the Board goes to rectify, he said.
He added that the procedure was documented in The Mandate, which was available to church members.
The bishop also warned against treating churches as family property or personal businesses.
“If you want to leave a church as an inheritance for your family, the Church has died,” he said.
He further cautioned founders against compelling their children to take up ministry roles, arguing that such pressure could frustrate their individual destinies.
The positions expressed by the three clerics reflect different approaches to succession planning in large religious organisations.
Adeboye has said he is waiting for divine revelation about his successor, while Kumuyi insists that church leadership should not be treated as a family inheritance.
Oyedepo, meanwhile, has outlined a documented procedure involving nominees and designated church bodies.
The debate has gained renewed relevance following the disagreement at The Fountain of Life Church, where the trustees who announced Jimmy Odukoya’s removal maintain that their decision stands, while Odukoya and his supporters dispute its constitutional validity.
Also read: Musk regrets spending millions on failed US election campaigns
The competing claims have raised questions about governance, institutional authority and the processes through which leadership is transferred in churches founded around prominent spiritual figures.
Peculiar Adirika is a journalist and contributor to Freelanews.com, covering news, business, and public affairs.























